finance 7 min read

Home Prices Are Falling in More Than Half of America's Biggest Cities

The Case-Shiller index shows national home prices up just 0.7% year-over-year in March, with more than half of major metros now declining. Seattle is down 2.5%. Denver is down 2%. Here's what the math looks like for buyers right now.

A new house listed for sale on Prieur Street in the Broadmoor neighborhood of New Orleans

A new house listed for sale on Prieur Street in the Broadmoor neighborhood of New Orleans — Photo: Infrogmation of New Orleans

By DopeCalculators Team

Published May 29, 2026

The S&P Cotality Case-Shiller index released data on May 26 showing that more than half of the 20 major U.S. housing markets posted year-over-year price declines in March 2026. The national index was up just 0.7% from a year earlier, the weakest annual gain since mid-2023 and the 14th consecutive month of slowing price growth.

That 0.7% sounds like a small positive. It isn't, really. With consumer prices (CPI) running at 3.3% annually, home values have now fallen in real, inflation-adjusted terms for 10 straight months. Buyers are paying more for money and getting less appreciation for it than at any point in several years.

The City-by-City Picture

The national average obscures a split that's getting starker. A few Midwest and Northeast metros are still posting real gains. Most of the Sun Belt and West are not.

The strongest markets in March: Chicago (+6.1%), New York (+4.0%), and Cleveland (+3.0%). These three are genuinely outpacing inflation. Chicago in particular has been a consistent outlier — its housing market never ran as hot as the Sun Belt during the pandemic boom, so it didn't have as far to fall.

The weakest markets tell a different story. Seattle declined 2.5% year-over-year, Denver fell 2.0%, Tampa dropped 1.9%, Dallas lost 1.7%, and both Phoenix and Los Angeles slid 1.6%. Washington D.C. also dipped into negative territory.

These are not markets that peaked and are finding equilibrium. These are markets where sellers are holding firm and buyers are walking away. According to Nicholas Godec, Head of Fixed Income Tradables & Commodities at S&P, the spread between the best and worst performing cities reached 8.6 percentage points in March, reflecting a market where geography is doing a lot of the work.

Mortgage Rates Are Not Helping

As of this week, the 30-year fixed-rate mortgage is averaging 6.53%, according to Bankrate. That's essentially unchanged from the past several months, and forecasters don't expect it to drop meaningfully below 6% this year.

At 6.53% on a $400,000 home with 20% down, you're looking at a monthly payment of roughly $2,020 for principal and interest alone. Add property taxes, insurance, and any HOA fees, and the total monthly cost climbs considerably higher. For comparison, the median U.S. existing home sale price in April was $417,700, per the National Association of Realtors.

This is the bind. Prices have come off their peaks in many cities, but not by enough to offset the cost of financing at today's rates. The result is a standoff: buyers can't make the math work at current prices, sellers don't want to cut, and transaction volume stays low.

If you want to run your own scenario, the Mortgage Calculator lets you plug in any price, down payment, and rate to see exactly what the monthly payment looks like. The Amortization Calculator breaks down how much of each payment goes to principal versus interest over time, which is especially important to understand when rates are this high.

Is It Still Cheaper to Rent?

The answer varies dramatically by city, which is the most honest answer available.

Nationally, buying is cheaper than renting in roughly 57% of U.S. counties, according to The Mortgage Reports. But that figure skews heavily toward less expensive Midwest and Southern markets. In the 50 largest metros, renting is cheaper in 27 of them. On the West Coast, renting is almost universally the better deal on a monthly basis right now.

The problem with the monthly comparison is that it ignores what happens over time. If you rent for 10 years, you pay rent and build no equity. If you buy, you pay a higher monthly cost but are slowly paying down principal while the asset (hopefully) appreciates. Whether buying wins in the long run depends on your market, how long you stay, how prices move, and what you'd do with the difference if you rented instead.

The Rent vs. Buy Calculator is built specifically for this comparison. You can enter your local rent, a purchase price, your assumed rate, expected price appreciation, and how long you plan to stay. It calculates the break-even point and shows the 10- and 20-year wealth projections for each option. In markets like Seattle or Denver where prices are actively declining, the break-even timeline looks very different from a market like Chicago where prices are still rising.

What "Real" Price Declines Mean for Buyers

Ten consecutive months of negative real returns on home values is significant, but it shouldn't be mistaken for a crash. Home prices peaked in mid-2022, fell sharply in 2022 and early 2023, then stabilized and started climbing again. What's happening now is a slower grind: prices are flat to slightly down in nominal terms in many markets, and inflation is eating the rest.

For buyers, that creates two ways to think about the current moment.

The optimistic read: prices have already corrected in the Sun Belt and West, inventory is rising, and sellers are finally becoming more flexible. If you find a house at the right price in Seattle or Phoenix, you're not buying at the peak.

The cautious read: mortgage rates are still well above what most existing homeowners locked in during 2020 and 2021, creating a "rate lock" effect where few people want to sell. That keeps supply constrained even as demand softens, which limits how far prices can actually fall. And if you buy at 6.5% and rates eventually drop to 5%, you'll refinance, but you still paid 6.5% for however many years that took.

Neither framing is wrong. The decision comes down to your personal timeline, local market conditions, and how stable your income is. The Home Affordability Calculator can help you figure out what price range makes sense given your income, debt, and how much you can put down, without stretching into territory that would make a rough stretch financially dangerous.

What to Watch Next

The next Case-Shiller release will cover April data and arrives in late June. Given that mortgage rates climbed slightly through April and pending home sales have ticked up three months in a row (a sign of latent demand), April could show a modest stabilization. Or not. The gap between asking prices and what buyers are willing to pay hasn't closed yet.

The Federal Reserve's next move matters here too. Two rate increases are now expected in 2026, per the Stanford Institute for Economic Policy Research, the opposite of what most housing market observers were hoping for at the start of the year. If that materializes, mortgage rates stay elevated or move higher. The affordability math gets harder, not easier.

For now, the data says the housing market is in a genuine slowdown in most of the country's largest cities. That's useful information whether you're trying to decide whether to rent or buy, whether to hold or list, or just trying to understand what's happening to the single biggest asset most Americans will ever own.

Run the numbers with our Mortgage Calculator, Rent vs. Buy Calculator, Home Affordability Calculator, and Amortization Calculator to see how your specific situation stacks up against the current market.

Sources